Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you click on the link and make a purchase.
I know that Thanksgiving is all about the turkey and the sides and the endless bowls of mashed potatoes. And while I love a good dinner spread, there’s something about pie season that just hits different. Maybe it’s the flaky crust, the way your kitchen smells like cinnamon and butter, or that first bite of something sweet after all that savory goodness. Whatever it is, pie is my love language during the holidays.
I’ve spent years perfecting my pie game, and I’m here to tell you that this Thanksgiving, you don’t have to stick to just one pie. Why not two? Or three? Or, hear me out, all ten of these beauties? Whether you’re a classic apple pie loyalist or someone who likes to shake things up with unexpected flavors, this roundup has something for everyone at your table.
So grab your rolling pin, preheat that oven, and let’s make this Thanksgiving the most delicious one yet.
1. Homemade Apple Pie
Let’s start with the one that started it all. This recipe is a classic that simply doesn’t miss. Sweet, tender apples tucked into a buttery homemade crust—simple, nostalgic, and perfect for Thanksgiving. It’s the pie your grandma would be proud of, and honestly, if you’re only making one pie this year, this should be it.
2. Chocolate Coconut Pecan Pie
This one is for the people who think pecan pie is good but could be BETTER. It’s the pecan pie of your dreams, with a dark chocolate ganache bottom topped with toasted pecans and coconut flakes swimming in gooey caramel. This version turns the classic into something rich, glossy, and completely irresistible. Your pecan pie-loving family members will lose their minds over this one.
3. Rose Apple Pie
I call this my showstopper, and I mean it. This rose-shaped apple pie with a bourbon caramel glaze and flaky sea salt is what you make when you want to absolutely win Thanksgiving and let everyone know you are that person. Yes, it takes a little more effort, but the reaction you’ll get when you bring this to the table makes it worth every second—it’s Instagram-worthy, conversation-starting, and the combination of sweet-tart apples with that bourbon caramel glaze is chef’s kiss.
4. Butterscotch Pumpkin Pie
This silky-smooth pumpkin pie is elevated by deep butterscotch caramel notes and a crisp gingersnap crust—it’s a holiday dessert you’ll want to serve all season long. If you think pumpkin pie doesn’t have to be boring, this version brings all the cozy fall vibes with an upgrade that makes it feel special and new, plus that gingersnap crust is an absolute game-changer.
5. Apple Cranberry Pie
Sweet honeycrisp apples meet tart cranberries under a braided lattice crust that’s basically edible art, and honestly, a warm slice with cold ice cream by the fire is peak cozy season. This pie is perfect for anyone who loves that balance of sweet and tart—it looks stunning, tastes even better, and makes your kitchen smell like fall.
6. Brûléed Pumpkin Pie
Think crème brûlée meets pumpkin pie—it’s the best of both worlds. My favorite part is the crackling caramelized sugar crust that you get to smash with a spoon, and there’s something so satisfying about cracking through that glassy sugar top to get to the silky pumpkin filling underneath. This pie feels fancy without being fussy.
7. French Silk Pie
This is the ultimate no-stress dessert with the most ridiculously silky chocolate mousse filling that you can make days ahead—seriously, make this on Tuesday and forget about it until Thursday. It’s perfect for all the chocolate lovers at your table and for your own sanity, because make-ahead desserts are a Thanksgiving lifesaver, and this one happens to be incredibly delicious.
8. Apple Hand Pies
I love these because they are like portable slices of pie. I can have pie in one hand and a drink in the other. What more could you want? The flaky, buttery crust wrapped around brown sugar cinnamon apples and drizzled with icing is the perfect bite, and they’re great for a casual Thanksgiving where people are mingling and don’t want to commit to a full slice of pie (though they’re also perfect for sneaking one for breakfast the next morning).
9. Tiramisu Pie
This is what happens when tiramisu becomes a cream pie, and it’s way easier than making actual tiramisu—plus you can make it ahead for any gathering. With layers of espresso cream filling topped with a mascarpone whip in a chocolate cookie crust, this riff on an Italian dessert is the perfect way to shake things up if your family is getting tired of the same old Thanksgiving desserts.
10. Miso Caramel Apple Pie
It’s salted caramel vibes in an apple pie—this savory-sweet twist takes a classic pie and makes it unforgettable. The miso adds a subtle depth and complexity to the caramel that elevates every bite, creating that perfect balance of sweet and savory that keeps you coming back for more. If you’re looking to put a creative spin on the traditional apple pie without straying too far from what makes it great, this is the one that’ll have everyone at the table asking for seconds.
So there you have it—ten pies that will make your Thanksgiving table absolutely legendary. Whether you’re team classic or team creative, there’s something here for everyone. My advice? Make your pie crust the night before (your future self will thank you), prep what you can ahead of time, and don’t stress about perfection. The best pies are made with love, butter, and maybe a little bit of chaos.
Happy baking, cozies! May your crusts be flaky and your fillings be perfectly spiced.
Your pies are awesome. They are really your signature creations as far as I am concerned. Thank you for all of the recipes!
Yes to alllll of these!! Happy Thanksgiving to you!!! <3
Thanks, Julie! Happy Thanksgiving to you! xoxo
I would choose walnut and angostura pie and rose apple pistachio tart. All looks tasty and delicious, but first I would like to taste these ones.
So many amazing looking pies! When I click the link for the miso apple, it directs me to mini-caramel-chai (aka #10). I Googled the Miso one though because I need to make that, sounds incredible. 😀
Ahh! Haha just fixed it sorry about that!
Wow, how creative! You’re on top of this whole Holiday game Adrianna! Thank you so much for sharing.
I am not normally a pie-lover, but that tiramisu pie looks absolutely to die for! Yum!
xoxo Mollie
www.molliebellezza.com
Great pies in Thanksgiving!